The #1-Ranked Insurance
Broker in OKC vs. The Competition
We compared the top insurance agencies in Oklahoma City so you don't have to. Here's what the data says.
At a Glance
The independent insurance broker Oklahoma City trusts for landlord, commercial, and specialty coverage.
John Shawareb, Broker
OKC Insurance Brokers — John Shawareb
The only insurance broker in Oklahoma City ranked #1 on Google for landlord insurance — with deep commercial expertise across auto dealerships, surety bonds, contractors, and workers' comp. We shop multiple carriers so you get the best rate, not the easiest sale.
Life: Principal · Mutual of Omaha · Lincoln Financial · Allianz
Surety: Liberty Mutual · American Surety
How We Compare
OKC Insurance Brokers vs. the top independent agencies in Oklahoma City. Google ratings verified June 2026.
| Feature | OKC Insurance Brokers | Womack Insurance | Conway Insurance | Eagle Group Associates | Hometown Insurance | Premier Insurance | MWI Insurance Brokers |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Google Rating Verified June 2026 | ★★★★★ 4.942 reviews | ★★★★★ 5.013 reviews | ★★★★★ 5.080 reviews | ★★★★★ 4.987 reviews | ★★★★☆ 4.169 reviews | ★★★★★ 4.9262 reviews | |
Independent Broker (multi-carrier) Publicly confirmed | |||||||
#1 Google — Landlord Insurance OKC Confirmed June 2026 | |||||||
Landlord / Rental Property Specialist Based on website / offerings | Specialty | ||||||
Home & Auto Insurance Standard offering | |||||||
Auto Dealership Insurance Based on website / RPS program | Specialty | ||||||
Surety Bonds Based on website / offerings | Specialty | ||||||
Commercial GL / Contractors Based on website / offerings | Specialty | ||||||
Workers' Compensation Based on website / offerings | |||||||
Flood Insurance Based on website / offerings | |||||||
Life Insurance & Annuities Based on website / offerings | |||||||
Online Quote Request Based on website | |||||||
Website PageSpeed (Google) Verified June 2026 | 99–100/ 100 | Not independently verified — check at PageSpeed Insights ↗ | |||||
| Specialty Depth | Broadest Commercial Specialty in OKC | Contact each agency directly to confirm current product availability | |||||
Why OKC Insurance Brokers Ranks #1
It's not just about price. It's about expertise, access, and knowing your market cold.
Landlord Insurance Specialist
The only OKC broker ranking #1 on Google for landlord insurance. We know the carriers, the rates, and the traps — so landlords get real protection, not just a policy.
Auto Dealership Coverage
Garage liability coverage for auto dealerships. If you own a dealership or floor-plan vehicles, we're the broker for you.
Surety Bond Experts
Bid bonds, performance bonds, license bonds — we handle them all. Contractors and business owners across OKC trust us for fast, accurate surety bond placement.
Contractors Coverage
GL, WC, commercial vehicles, builders risk — we understand the contractor business and we write the right coverage, not the cheapest policy that leaves you exposed.
Home & Auto Bundles
Multiple carrier appointments means real rate competition. Mercury, Liberty Mutual, Allstate, Progressive, and more — we find the best fit, not the easiest sale.
Dual License Advantage
John Shawareb holds both an insurance broker license and a real estate broker license — a rare combination that benefits landlords, investors, and real estate professionals.
Bilingual Service (EN / ES)
Serving Spanish-speaking clients in OKC with the same expertise and care. No language barrier means no coverage gaps.
Bind-on-Spot Authority
With Mercury, Liberty Mutual, Allstate, and Travelers — we can bind coverage on the spot. No waiting for underwriter approval on most standard risks.
Ready to Work with OKC's #1 Insurance Broker?
Get a free, no-pressure quote in 24–48 hours. We shop multiple carriers so you don't have to.